The Machine Works
Sitting at the back of a courtroom of the 53rd circuit court in Cheboygan, Michigan, I jot down these ‘criminal justice highlights’ of the life of a defendant. They are presented when the judge summarizes the history of convictions and incarcerations of the accused prior to sentencing.
The courtroom is located in a small rural city of less than 5,000 people. 2024 data indicates that the per capita income for Cheboygan is $31,000 (state wide it is $40,534) with around 20% living below the poverty line. The median household income for the city sits roughly 35–40% below the state average.
Parole
In many states, including Michigan, courts impose a prison sentence range with a minimum and maximum term. The minimum time served is typically the earliest point an inmate becomes eligible for parole board review, while the maximum is the absolute limit of incarceration. Parole acts as a mechanism for conditional early release. If the parole board deems the inmate rehabilitated, they are released on parole to serve the remainder of their sentence under supervision. Failing a parole condition can mean going back to prison to serve more of the original maximum time.
Criminal justice in practise
One can argue whether the emphasis of sentencing, imprisonment, parole etc. should be on punishment, containment, determent or even rehabilitation. Reading this overview might evoke the idea that the system is broken, but I am assured several times: No, it’s functioning perfectly.
This case shows our criminal justice system is working prefectly, as designed! Despite this the judge remarks, hiding his disapproval (and disappointment?): This is a life of nothing but crime.
1963, A boy is born.
It is the start of a life during which he will receive over 50 criminal convictions.
1978, age 15
His first felony conviction comes following a breaking and entering charge in 1978 when he was only 15 years old. He is put on juvenile probation in December 1978.
1979, age 16
That next May, 1979, he is arrested in Louisiana as a runaway and returned to Michigan. A month later, June 1979, he is arrested in Florida for vagrancy and returned to Michigan. In December 1979, he commits his 2nd juvenile felony, called Receiving and concealing stolen property (a special Michigan crime definition) involving the purchase, receipt, possession, or concealment of stolen, embezzled, or converted property with knowledge of its illicit origin.
1980, age 17
He is send to the maximum-security juvenile correctional facility located in Whitmore Lake in March of 1980. (That facility was closed in 2015) He absconds on September 3, 1980 but is caught that same day.
Later that month he absconds again. Juvenile work camps are easy to walk away from.
1981, age 18
In April 1981, he is arrested for a breaking and entering act and, being 18, convicted of his first adult felony. And this resulted in his first time of actually going to prison for 18 months to 5 years. This being a low security prison, he escapes from prison.
And then while on the run, he is arrested in September 29, 1981 for driving without a license, so he returns to prison.
About 3 months later, he escapes from the prison’s work camp again on New Year’s Eve, 1981.
1982, age 19
He’s arrested a couple weeks later on January 12, 1982. While back in prison, he commits several offenses, referred to as misconducts. Despite his, he is paroled in early 1983.
1983, age 20
Within a couple months, he is arrested for a felony larceny case: the unlawful taking and carrying away of another person’s property with the intent to permanently deprive them of it.
And he is, once more, sentenced to prison: One year to 2.5 years. They parole him before the 2.5 years are up.
1988, age 25
On September 30th, 1988 he is arrested for another felony crime: Breaking and entering. And so it is back to prison for 18 months to 5 years.
They parole him in 1990.
1992, age 29
He is arrested again in April 1992 for a misdemeanor resisting arrest and gets a sentence of 30 days jail. After the 30 days he is out back on parole. He absconds to that parole, is caught and thus goes back to prison.
And again, for the 3rd time, he escapes prison custody. While in prison, several misconducts are put on the record again. This delays his parole until 1995
1995, age 32
Released from prison, he makes it about half a year until he is arrested again. Driving on a suspended license, 10 days jail.
1996, age 33
Then a couple months later, August 1996, he is arrested for drunk driving which puts him in jail for 45 days.
1999, age 36
He is arrested for driving while intoxicated. He pleads guilty on August 9th of 1999.
On September 13, 1999, everybody’s assembled for sentencing, but he is not there: He fails to appear for sentencing.
2000, age 37
On March 29 2000, while having failed to appear for a sentencing for Operating While Intoxicated (OWI) 3rd, he is arrested in Shevoyan County for another OWI 3rd degree.
So on August 14 and 15 2000, he is sentenced in both counties.
In Prescio County, the judge says: back to prison, 3 years to 7.5 years. In Sheboygan County: back to prison, 23 months to 5 years. While he is in prison, more misconduct is put on his record sheet.
2003, age 40
After about 3 years in prison he is paroled on December 16th, 2003. It was not a successful parole.
Because about 3 months later, he faces the courts again for driving on a suspended license and drinking violations: together with break-ins. A persistent theme of his life.
He pleads guilty to receiving and concealing stolen property over $20,000.
For anyone keeping score, that would be, I think, his 10th felony conviction.
So back to prison it is, following being sentenced to 3 years, 10 months minimum, 20 years maximum.
He is imprisoned for that minimum and is paroled. But again, he violates parole, within just a few months: driving with a suspended license. So more local jail and paroled. While on parole, arrested for another felony repeat drunk driving. This means back to prison to serve out more of the maximum sentence.
2009, age 46
Arrested for burglary in 2009 and sentenced on November 10, 2009 to 3.5 to 7.5 year. He is eligible for parole on August 2014.
2014, age 51
On August 9, 2014, he is release on parole, and this time he does have a successful parole discharge.
About 7 weeks later, he is arrested for selling drugs. Dealing and using Meth has become part of his life now.
Back to prison, for the 12th and 13th felony convictions. Prison time for 20 months to 10.5 years. After that 20 months minimum, he is paroled.
2016, age 52
About 4.5 months later, November 1, 2016, he is arrested for selling drugs again this time while on parole. Back to prison he goes for another prison sentence, 20 months to 7 years.
2019, age 55
He is paroled in December 2019.
About a month and a half later, in January 2020 he is arrested for traffic misdemeanors in Emmett County, including driving on a suspended license. And again, he fails to appear for court.
2023, age 59
There is still an outstanding warrant for his arrest in an accounting for that 2019 case. He is arrested and on March 28, 2023 he gets another sentence: 34 months to 20 years in prison for the possession of meth.
2025, age 61
Parole issued on July 9th, 2025. Couple months later, on September 16, he absconds probation. Caught on October 22, 2025 and detained, but 8 days later, parole was reinstated. In the meantime he has 2 positive drug tests for methamphetamine.
Therefore he is instructed by the parole agent to get into a treatment program. That last positive test and that conversation with parole agent was December 2nd, 2025.
Instead of following that advice, he instead buys more methamphetamine, inject it, and drives again with a suspended license.
He is stopped. He resists and obstructs the commands of the officers at the scene. He attempts to destroy concealed evidence consisting of his cell phone. A baggy of meth is found in the car.
When he later consents to a search of the phone, police discovered evidence of drug activity, as well as photos and videos of him holding and shooting an AR 15 style rifle at a location in Chibot County.
So in late 2025 he is sentenced to minimum of 9 years and 1 month, maximum of 28 years, meaning he won’t be paroled before 2035, at which time he will be in his 70ies. And, who knows, we can pick up this roulette at that time. The judge has made up his mind: This is a life of nothing but crime.
After pronouncing this latest sentence, says the judge: ’Good luck to you, sir.’
As I recently found out, these proceedings were at the time I attended the courtroom being streamed live on the internet. They have been archived and are now available for all to see that The system is functioning perfectly, in other words: the machine works.